Good Intentions, Bad Outcomes: Stick To The Script During Terminations

A Mississippi steakhouse, Diamond Jim's Mrs. Donna's Ole Farm Beef LLC, was sued by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on behalf of a worker.

According to the allegations, when she was hired, the worker disclosed that she had a seizure condition. However, she explained that she had not had a seizure in years. After a few months on the job, the worker allegedly had a seizure related to her condition.

Shortly after learning of the employee's seizure, the steakhouse allegedly fired her and said she should "focus on her health".

Source: https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/eeoc-sues-diamond-jims-and-mrs-donnas-disability-discrimination

Commentary

The above case illustrates how comments can be damaging during terminations. "Focus on [your] health" may have been intended as well-meaning; even so, it led to the federal government filing a discrimination charge in federal court.

Managers or supervisors may want to soften the blow of a termination by offering platitudes or other phrases intended to make the dismissed employee feel better. However, when those phrases or comments are made during a termination and reference an employee's disability or other protected status, they may create a direct link between the employee's protected status and the decision to terminate.

When terminating an employee, employers should:

· Ensure conversations are short and to-the-point

· Avoid any reference to the employee's health, recovery, and/or anything else related to disability status

· Ensure the stated reason for termination is properly documented and is not an illegal reason based on disability status

· Provide discrimination prevention training to managers and supervisors, which includes information regarding proper language and phrasing during performance reviews, terminations, and other employment-related conversations.

The final takeaway is no matter how well meaning a comment during a termination may be, it can lead to misinterpretation and risk. The best practice is to stick to the script.

Finally, your opinion is important to us. Please complete the opinion survey: